All hell breaks loose as nuns shake their buns
AN unholy row has erupted over Brumby’s bakery’s latest television campaign, which depicts nuns singing the praises of their bread products.
In the offending gospel-inspired advertisement, a choir – including of habit-wearing nuns – sing "Give us this day our daily bread" as they sing and dance around Brumby’s products.
Brumby’s managing director Michael Sherlock said Victorian-based Missionary Sisters of Service nun Sister Marcia McMahon had complained to the Advertising Standards Bureau, saying the ad was offensive and made a mockery of the Celebration of the Eucharist.
Mr Sherlock said the ad was loosely based on the Blues Brothers film and was designed to be memorable, not controversial.
"We can see their point, but we’re not denigrating (nuns) in any way," he said.
"We’ve gone back and reviewed what we did and we feel we haven’t deliberately set out to offend anybody and we feel on reflection it doesn’t offend most people."
Mr Sherlock said the complaint was an "overreaction’ and there was no suggestion Brumby’s would pull the ad, which had received a lot of positive feedback.
"It’s working well for us. We’ve examined it to see if there is any offence and we’re satisfied it doesn’t," he said.
Hey it is working well with us to sell bread so to heck with anybody that has a problem with it and it doesn’t offend most people. Yep, that is a great advertising maxim – not offending most people. Now I am not usually easily offended by the secular use of Catholic imagery. I don’t see all commercials involving nuns as an attack. It is interesting though just how many advertisers have this fascination with Catholic nuns that doesn’t seem to apply to other religions. Just placing nuns in any secular setting is suppose to elicit some laughs. The image of nuns dancing around with loaves of bread and singing is pretty silly, though not really an attack against the Eucharist. Just an attempt at cheap laughs when advertising ideas run out.
Update: You can see the commercial for yourself here.
Incidentally, the commercial in question can be seen on the company’s website:
How any company could put together this ad, without it occurring to them that some would find it offensive, escapes me.
I’m now looking forward to my next trip to Australia, so I can not buy their products.
funnily enough I couldn’t hear most of it. Act of God to prevent my catachumenate ears from hearing blasphemous material?
This is what comes of Catholics’ being all gentle and tolerant and self-effacing. I have been saying for years that we need to take a leaf out of the Anti-Defamation League’s book and become tetchy and demanding in the extreme. That’s why nobody makes ha-ha-it’s-funny commercials with rabbis acting like idiots. Get picky and get aggressive, folks.
I have questions about being a nun.
I want to know more about being a nun.
I do not know I just feel a need to become closer to God and the wonderful man on the cross Jesus.
The only way to get closer is church and walking in a more Biblical way for him.
Spiritually, I want something that church or people cannot give me with God. His divine love is so unique and powerful.
Can you help me with this issue and questions?
Such as who to talk to about the sister and how to become one.
Sharon K Armstrong
210 E. 6th 3
Dewey, OK 74029
Comments are closed.