The validity of the relic is at stake

Comment(s) (8) | TrackBacks (0)

GARCHES, France (AP) — A team of experts plans a series of tests to determine whether Joan of Arc's supposed remains — a rib bone and some skin — may indeed have belonged to the 15th-century French heroine burned at the stake after a trial for heresy.

It is thought that the ashes of Joan of Arc, now a saint and a legend, were thrown into the River Seine. However, a few remains were reportedly recovered from the pyre where the 19-year-old warrior was burned alive.

The tests, which will take six months, will not be able to say with certainty that the remains are Joan of Arc's, because there is no known DNA sample from her to compare the bone and skin against, said Dr. Philippe Charlier of the Raymond-Poincare Hospital in Garches, west of Paris.

But the analyses will determine with "absolute certitude" if the remains are not hers, he added at a news conference.

The complexities are numerous. Charlier said Joan of Arc was actually burned three times May 30, 1431, following her trial in the Normandy town of Rouen. She initially died of smoke inhalation and when she was burned a second time, internal organs were not fully consumed by the flames. Nothing was said to remain after the third cremation except her ashes.

The rib bone measuring some 15 centimetres is wrapped in a blackish substance, and is "remarkably well preserved," said Charlier.

"We will first have to assure that this rib corresponds with a 19-year-old woman," with DNA testing used to determine the sex, he added. [Source]

 

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: The validity of the relic is at stake.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.splendoroftruth.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/3449

8 Comments

Whoa, this all seems like such a stretch! To go so far to prove that something MIGHT be something but definitely, possibly isn't something...for sure? Seems like someone's got a whole heck of a lot of time on their hands!

Too bad (Bl. ?)Sr. Anne Catherine Emmerick isn't alive any more. She was able to just touch a bone or object and tell you what saint it belonged to with complete certainty.

I wonder if they'll use the same labs that carbon dated the Shroud of Turin? They'll probably tell us that the relics are forgeries from 1956, and that the rib bone actually belongs to Edith Piaf.

Completely bogus. The English and their perfidious bishop, Pierre Cauchon, would never have taken the chance that there were actual remains of Joan left to be venerated. To the partisans of Charles VII she was already a living saint. Relics would have even more power. There is no way to tell if bits of bone are her are just some other sad character who just happened ot be burned there.

. . . Joan of Arc was actually burned three times May 30, 1431, following her trial in the Normandy town of Rouen. She initially died of smoke inhalation and when she was burned a second time, internal organs were not fully consumed by the flames. Nothing was said to remain after the third cremation except her ashes.

Is it too late to get angry about this?

Typical, some scientific tests that at worse will say, "Your relics are a fraud," and at best well say "I guee we'll never know."

Re: Agnes Sorel bit in news story --

What, a famous medieval beauty who needed her looks to live, and she died of mercury poisoning? Oh, that'd never happen!

*end sarcasm*

Mercury was used in cosmetics from Roman times on.

Part of the legend of Joan of Arc is that her heart would not burn. There are even statements from her executioner saying this.

Yes the Greek Captcha is a joke

Leave a comment

The Curt Jester

A former atheist who after spending forty years in the wilderness finds himself with both astonishment and joy a member of the Catholic Church. This blog presents my hopefully humorous and sometimes serious take on things religious, political, and whatever else crosses my mind.

My conversion story

Email Me:

Blessed Miguel Pro, S.J.

Known as "God's Jester" was a martyr for the faith and a man of wisdom, fun, tricks, poetry, song, and dance. Thus seemed an appropriate Patron Saint of this blog.

Shameless Promotion

The Curt Jester: Disturbingly Funny --Mark Shea
EX-cellent blog --Jimmy Akin
One wag has even posted a list of the Top Ten signs that someone is in the grip of "motu-mania," -- John Allen Jr.
Brilliance abounds --Victor Lams
The Curt Jester is a blog of wise-ass musings on the media, politics, and things "Papist." The Revealer
Not all the Jester’s lines hit their target. --Commonweal
2009 Award Nominee Funniest Blog

Info

Blogging since:
7/24/02

This site established:
9 Feb 2003

My Previous blog
Atheist to a Theist

Catholic since:
Easter 4/4/99

Human since:
Conception 1958

Sponsors

My other blogs

Real Sponsors

Archives

Supernatural Weather

Site Meter

Powered by Movable Type 4.23-en

Navigation

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Subscribe

Atom
RSS

Catholic Sites

Catholic Podcasts




SQPN is a source for great Catholic podcasts.

Ministerial Bloghood

Bloghood of the Faithful

A Catholic Life
A Catholic Mom Climbing the Pillars
A Catholic Mom in Hawaii
Acts of the Apostasy
Ad Altare Dei
AdoroTeDevote
Alive and Young
A (little) Light from the East
Against the Grain
Aggie Catholics
And Sometimes Tea
Aliens in this world
American Chesterton Society
American Papist
Among Women
Ask Sister Mary Martha
Assenting Catholic
auntie joanna writes
A Wing And A Prayer
Bay Area Catholic
bettnett.com
Bethune Catholic
Big C Catholics
Blackadder's Lair
Blog by-the-Sea
Cacciaguida
Catholic Analysis
Catholic and Enjoying It!
Catholic Cartoon Blog
Catholic in Film School
Catholic in Japan Catholic Fire
Catholic Mom of 10
Catholic New Media Roundup
Catholic Pillow Fight
Catholic with Attitude
Claw of the Conciliator
Chad Is Not Enough
Chris Cuddy
Church of the Masses
Christus Vincit
Confessions of a Hot Carmel Sundae
Concordia cum Veritate
Conversion Diary
Cor ad cor loquitur
Cosmos-Liturgy-Sex
Creative Minority Report
CUF Blog
CVSTOS FIDEI
Dad29
dark speech upon the harp
Darwin Catholic
Defenders of the Catholic Faith
Defensor Veritatis
Dei Gratia
Deo Omnis Gloria
Disputations
Divine Life
Dominican Idaho
Dyspectic Mutterings
Eagle and Elephant
Ecce Homo
Erik's Rants and Recipes
Eve Tushnet
feminine-genius
Fiat
FideCogitActio
Fighting Irish Thomas
FIRST THINGS: On the Square
Five Feet of Fury
Flos Carmeli
Flying Stars
For The Greater Glory
Galactic Catholic Universe
Gen X Revert
Get Religion
GKC's Favourite
God's Wonderful Love
Godsbody
Happy Catholic
HMS Blog
If Flannery Had A Blog
Holy Cards For Your Inspiration
In Defense Of The Children of Light
In Dwelling
InForum Blog
In Light of the Law
Ignatius Insight Scoop
In Nomine Domini
Jeff Cavins
Jimmy Akin
John C. Wright
Jumping Without A Chute
June Cleaver after a Six Pack
Kansas Catholic
La Salette Journey
L.A. Catholic
Laudem Gloriae
Lamb of God
Laus Crucis
Lex Communis
Life is a Prayer
Live + Jesus!
Lofted Nest
Looking Closer Journal
Laodicea
Loved Undefiled
Man with Black Hat
Maria Lectrix
Mary Meets Dolly
mere comments
M. J. Joachim on Catholic Catechism & More
Mommentary
MONIALES OP
Mount Carmel Bloggers
Mulier Fortis
Musings of a Pertinacious Papist
My Domestic Church
Nunblog
Oblique House
Off the Record
Oklahomily
Open wide the doors to Christ!
Patrick Madrid
Pro Ecclesia * Pro Familia * Pro Civitate
Ramblings of a Catholic Soccer Mom
Real Clear Religion
Recta Ratio
Rerum Novarum
Rise of the TOB
Ruri et Orbi
Roman Catholic Blog
RORATE CÆLI
Sacramentum Vitae
Seize the Dei
Shades of Gray (Umbrae Canarum)
Shrine of the Holy Whapping
Some Have Hats
Sonitus Sanctus
Southern Appeal
Southfarthing Soapbox
Sterquilinium
Stony Creek Digest
Stupidus
Summa Contra Mundum
Summa Mamas
Testosterhome
Ten Reasons
The Anchoress
The Ark and The Dove
The Art of Apologetics
The B-Movie Catechism
The Blog from the Core
The Blue Boar
The Charcoal Fire
The Commonplace Book of Zadok the Roman
The Crescat/a>
The Daily Eudemon
The Dawn Patrol
The Digital Hairshirt
The Four Pillars
The Fifth Column
The Inn at the End of the World
The Ironic Catholic
The Lady in the Pew
The Lair of the Catholic Cavemen
The Lion and the Cardinal
The New Liturgical Movement
The Paragraph Farmer
The Ramblings, Rants, and Raves of John Book
The Roamin' Roman
The Sacred Page
The Sci Fi Catholic
The Scratching Post
Super(Catholic)Man
The Way of the Fathers
The Weight of Glory
The Wired Catholic
Thoughts and ruminations of a man on a quest
Thoughts of a Regular Guy
You say Tomato, I say Catholic
Thoughts of Apolonio Latar III
To Dust You Shall Return
Tremendous Trifles
Trousered Ape
True Confessions of a Prodigal Daughter
V for Victory!
Vatican Watcher
Veritas
Veritas nunquam perit
Via Media (Amy Welborn)
Vivificat
Video meliora, proboque; Deteriora sequor
Why Fret?
Wild Tangents
Zippy Catholic